Recent Discussions View Reviews
Page 1 (Showing 1-25) Next >
Song: Pendulum       "The Guitar Chart" Dead Player
I would like to aplaud Rythm Authors for charting what I would consider to be the best charted song I have ever played. A perfect mix of accuracy and fun that I haven't seen the likes of in god knows how long. Well done!
10.03.11 10:14am 0 Replies | Reply +1 Relevance
Song: My Way       "The Album Art" Dead Player
Kill it with fire.
10.02.11 7:31pm 1 Replies | Reply 0 Relevance
Pack: Slipknot 02       "The Absolute Worst of Harmonix" Dead Player
Unless you are a huge fan of the band or only playing drums, do NOT buy this pack! The guitar chart for Pulse of The Maggots is ridicoulously wrong and Wait and Bleed's outro goes extremely out of sync to the point where the song ends before the charted notes do.

Or, in other words:


EDIT: What on earth... in a sureal turn of events Harmonix actually DID fix their game by re-releasing the pack with the tempo error fixed. What a relief. The pack is still horrible on Guitar though, so Guitarists beware.
09.27.11 4:41pm 2 Replies | Reply +2 Relevance
Song: Pulse of the Maggots       "The Guitar Chart..." Dead Player
3 words:

09.27.11 11:18am 5 Replies | Reply +1 Relevance
Song: Children Surrender       "Gender Bender?" Dead Player
Umm... what gender is that person on the album art anyways? Or any of the band members for that matter.
09.24.11 7:41pm 4 Replies | Reply +1 Relevance
Song: Parallel Universe       "Silly Harmonix" Dead Player
God damnit Harmonix, stop screwing up the guitar chart for all my favorite songs!

EDIT: Huh, that actually wasn't as bad as I predicted. Pretty playable even if it was a bit random.
08.30.11 8:47pm 3 Replies | Reply 0 Relevance
Song: Wish You Were Here       "Wish You Were Here" Dead Player
Needs moar Pink Floyd.
08.23.11 10:39am 0 Replies | Reply +1 Relevance
Song: Parhelia       "Mixing" Dead Player
The mixing is pretty sloppy on this one, with errors such as the whole song being a few decibels under the standard volume of RB songs. If bad sound quality easly piss you off, beware.
08.03.11 7:07pm 0 Replies | Reply +1 Relevance
Song: Katsushika       "Undertier of the Century?" Dead Player
I know I probably say this alot, but this song is extremely, and I mean EXTREMELY undertiered on Guitar.

The Ho/Po patterns in the pre-choruses are completely batshit insane and it repeats atleast 2 times, and the song does also have a minute long superfast strum part, alot like East Jesus Nowhere's bridge, in the outro that will tire out the strumming hands of even the most proffesional of players.

This should atleast have been a tier 5.
07.29.11 11:07pm 4 Replies | Reply +1 Relevance
Song: Alaska       "Seizure Warning!" Dead Player
If you think Unfurling A Darkened Gospel was bad, this is even worse. There is alot, and I mean ALOT, of random flashy special effects going on in the background that might really mess your eyes up and in a worst case scenario trigger an epileptic seizure.

Buyers beware.

The song is also pretty bad on Guitar and Keys.
07.20.11 7:12pm 5 Replies | Reply +2 Relevance
Song: Betrayed       "Sepultura" Dead Player
Derrick Green, the new vocalist of Sepultura, is doing vocals on this song, so this is technically the closest thing to a Sepultura song in Rock Band as of now.

If we just could get some real Sepultura or some Cavalera Conspiracy as DLC...
07.18.11 3:34pm 0 Replies | Reply 0 Relevance
Song: Cool Concoction       "Fusion" Dead Player
This is aperantly the first song in the game to fall under the genre "Fusion"... if you look away from the fact that Fusion just means that the song mixes two or more genres, which means we already have a shitload if we count the Nu-Metal, Rock N Roll, Blues Rock, Prog and Metalcore songs already in the game.

In fact, I am not even sure how a basic MIDI song even fits into the Fusion genre to begin with.
07.10.11 12:03am 0 Replies | Reply +1 Relevance
Song: When You're Young       "Ripping Off" Dead Player
Dear lord, it's like if a ripoff of their other song ripped off Nickleback who then ripped off Seether... so it is kind of like a ripoff inside a ripoff of a ripoff.

06.28.11 3:38pm 4 Replies | Reply +3 Relevance
Song: Tubthumping       "Oh dear lord!" Dead Player
Creepiest album cover "art" of all time, and possibly a shared 1st place with We're An American Band on worst art aswell. This makes the Land of Rape and Honey cover look somewhat apealing to the eye and mind, which is saying alot.
06.12.11 9:00pm 8 Replies | Reply +3 Relevance
Song: Take on Me       "Predictions" Dead Player
I bet 10 fictional bucks that this will be devil tiered on Keys, undertiered as fuck on Vocals and boring as hell on Pro Guitar.

>No Keys solo

06.12.11 1:16am 8 Replies | Reply +1 Relevance
Song: Guitars SUCK       "Goodbye old friend" Dead Player
I always wished that I would see you come out for Real to the PS3. When the doctors at Harmonix said there was no chance of you pulling trough, it was the worst thing that had ever happened to me. Goodbye Guitars SUCK. You will be missed.


Alright, I am overreacting. Still, this sucks harder than all the guitars in the whole wide world togheter.
06.09.11 6:00pm 2 Replies | Reply +1 Relevance
Song: It's Gonna Be A Long Night       "Stupidest Band Devil Tier Ever." Dead Player
>None of the instrument parts goes over tier 4
>The song is relatively short
>Alot of easy to hit OD

To quote a different song:
"I don't know, I don't know.
Stick around, and it may show,
But I don't know, I don't know."
06.08.11 11:31am 8 Replies | Reply +1 Relevance
Song: The Good Left Undone       "That's alot of tripplechords." Dead Player
I mean seriously, who charted this? Beenox?

The other songs this week also seem to be suffering from Guitar Hero Tripplechord Syndrome.
06.07.11 12:46pm 2 Replies | Reply +1 Relevance
Song: Blood and Thunder       "Dat fills" Dead Player
Seriously, how is this not devil tiered on drums? I nearly failed out on my sightread in the second chorus for crying out loud, while most other Nightmare tier songs that I have played can I easly get 5 stars on (at times even gold).
06.03.11 3:06pm 2 Replies | Reply 0 Relevance
Song: Walk       "Celebration" Dead Player
The 17th of May is Norway's national day, alot like 4th of July is the national day of the USA. But while the others up here will celebrate how we are a free country, I will rather celebrate how we finaly get some good Pantera DLC. God/Satan bless Pantera and the masterpiece that is Vulgar Display of Power!

Also, why on earth is this song band-devil-tiered, and why ain't I even surprised?
05.16.11 11:03pm 2 Replies | Reply 0 Relevance
Song: Through the Fire and Flames       "Based on le True story" Dead Player
Dat outro.

I am surprised nobody made something similar earlier.
05.12.11 10:32pm 0 Replies | Reply +5 Relevance
Song: Blue Jean       "Abusing Album Art" Dead Player
Say, I looked at this album art, and I though to myself "David have quite a "wtf did I just watch"-ish face there". What do you think?

Oh and no, I am not a Bowie hater of any kind, infact I am a great fan of his Ziggy Stardust era.
05.10.11 9:00pm 1 Replies | Reply +3 Relevance
Song: Walk of Life       "Since everybody else is doing it..." Dead Player
This is simply the most over tiered song of ALL TIME on Guitar. The song is basically the same riff going on and on for about 3-4 minutes, and the riff isn't even hard! It is your basic half-fast alt-strummy riff that mixes single notes and chords (alot like Jesus Buildt My Hotrod and I Wanna Be Sedated) withot a solo or any over the top part. In fact, I would say this is a tier 3 tops, nothing more.

Harmonix, seriously, fire the people who tier your songs. They are no good at it.
05.02.11 11:47am 2 Replies | Reply +1 Relevance
Song: Rock and Roll All Nite (Live)       "Not again..." Dead Player
Well now this song is getting re-released so many times it is not even funny.

I would also like to ask if anyone have a pro tip on how to get this annoying tune out of ones head.
04.24.11 9:21pm 5 Replies | Reply 0 Relevance
Song: (pin)Ballz       "I hope you don't mind Saxy Man" Dead Player

You should consider making a version where he is pointing at the album art and not my avatar Saxy
04.22.11 8:49am 3 Replies | Reply 0 Relevance
Page 1 (Showing 1-25) Next >
62 Discussions
+59 Votes (76 Up / 17 Down)

Received 122 comments, posted 196 comments